tisdag 17 maj 2011

Will a general artificial intelligence be benevolent?

It is hard to predict what AIs will do, especially as we have problems to define what an AI is. If you take a chess program, most would define it as narrow AI. Good at chess, but worthless at other things. But how then do you make a general AI? And if you succeed to create one, what makes it do anyting at all? Why wouldn't it just sit there, thinking of something, and remain incommunicative?

I think one of the important building blocks of an AI is the driving force. The problem with chess programs is that the driving force is extremly narrow. It is something like "for each piece, try every possible move. For each of the tests, try every possible response. All the time, evaluate the situation according to a strictly defined algorithm". And some more. This doesn't give the program much ability to generalize.

If the computer instead would have a driving force more generally defined, as "play human opponents, goal is to win", then it would leave more room for out-of-the-box solutions. For example, you win more if the humans play worse. So one solution would be to select low talented opponents. Another solution that would fulfill the goal would be to somehow arrange to have the opponents killed, and win by walk-over. A program that can take this kind of very general definition of driving force doesn't exist yet. Even if the given example is extreme, more near future realistic examples can be imagined.

It is a version of the old adage "the way you ask something determines what kind of answer you get". I think the defined driving force, the algorithms, and the rules, are what will ultimately make up an AI. You don't really need the rules to make an AI, but I strongly encourage the use of them. Even if the driving force is seemingly benevolent, it is no guarantee of the eventual behaviour.

A discussion you see now and then is if the driving force should be copied from humans. Looking closer to this, I think the main human driving force is to spread your genes. Everything else is just a side effect, to improve the chance that you succeed. Behaving nice to people, even doing charity, improves the chance.

The hope is that using a human driving force for an AI would also give it the same behaviour. But I think that is a mistake, as the nice part of (most) human behaviour is only a side effect. There are spectacular examples of humans that succeed well on an individual point of view, but catastrophically from the point of view of the human civilization.

fredag 6 maj 2011

Intelligent spam

In the near future, maybe 5-10 years, we will start to see intelligent spam. There will be participators in discussions argumenting for a position. The discussion will be two-way, not the one-way we see from spam today. This intelligent spam will be created automatically by software, from goal and rules defined by a stake holder.

fredag 20 november 2009

So, what is really the Google Chrome OS?

So, what is really the Google Chrome OS?

Some people compares it with Linux, and see it as an UI addon with the Chrome browser, but they miss the point. Google Chrome OS is really a paradigm shift. The idea is that nothing (except a crypted cache) will be stored locally. Everything else will be stored in the cloud.

That means that if you switch from one notebook to another, you will get exactly the same thing and environment.

For example, there are discussions why Chrome OS only supports SSD, and not the old disk types. The reason is speed. And it will not be expensive as you will not need much storage.

Another questions is why only some selected platforms will be supported. Again, the idea is not that you should replace your OS at your current home computer. The idea is that the next generation notebooks, as well as smaller devices, will bring a new way to work.

måndag 2 november 2009

The goal of Google Wave

What is really the goal of Google Wave?

Is it to create a replacement for email?

Google have invited developers very early into the product process, long before most companies would open up access. I would say it is a form of Agile development. You get quick feedback on functionality, which makes it easier to find out what is really wanted.

I think Google doesn't really care what Google Wave is. They want to do something that people wants to use, and it doesn't really matter what it is as long as it gets popular. Because of that, the actual requirement specification is impossible to freeze early.

By involving users and developers this early, the Wave will have the possibility to evolve in a way that noone had anticipated.

Wave has some new ideas, or at least re-invented old ones. It is when you combine new ideas that real inventions are born. The type that few could have foreseen.

It will be interesting to see where this will lead. Will it be the next paradigm of Internet usage, or will be just another mail system?

fredag 9 oktober 2009

Uploading a mind to a computer and the art of music

A friend of mine, interested in the ultimate listening experience of music, once thought about what it would mean if you could upload your mind to a computer. So we had a discussion about that. The first though was that you could get rid of a number of analog transformations that added noise to the signal. That is, the music could be fed directly to the (simulated) ear nerves. And so you would get a totally loss-free music experience.

But why stop it at that? When you enjoy a piece of music, there is some kind of mechanism in the brain that do the analysis of the music, which in turns generates the pleasing feeling. Why not directly stimulate this pleasure mechanism? That means you don't need real music any more. Another problem with an uploaded mind could be that it may have almost perfect memory. I believe that surprise is one important part of music. Again, this shouldn't really be a problem if you can simply stimulate the surprise handling mechanisms, and no real surprises are needed.

But then you may as well take it to the next step. Why not directly stimulate the pleasure generating part of the brain, and get exactly the same satisfaction as when you listen to good music?

It can be questioned whether it is the actual experience of pleasure that is the important thing, or the memory of this experience. Why not skip the whole thing about stimulating pleasure, and instead plant a modified memory of having had the pleasure?

Somehow, this doesn't look attractive to me. But then, the technology of uploading probably isn't going to be available for quite a while yet.

lördag 3 oktober 2009

Google Wave and games?

There are many people who use email to send funny pictures and movies. It is not unusual for a film clip to come back again after a year, when it has spun around "on the Internet".

With Google Wave you can also attach games (in the form of extensions). I'm convinced that there will be will be a lot of people around the world who develop various funny things, which will then spread around on the Internet. Not only that, Google Wave supports multilayer games in real time. It is impossible to predict how these things will unfold, but it would not surprise me if many people that now send videos and pictures will feel compelled to switch to Google Wave so as not be left out.

This principle, to release forces free on the Internet, is extremely potent. There is an enormous creativity in "the world", waiting to be tapped. 20 years ago I started an experiment in the form of an online multiplayer adventure game where participants (after some effort) could extend the same game. It did not take long until the whole world (in the game) literally exploded by the most extraordinary ideas that I never could have imagined.

Of course, I really hope that there will be no problems with viruses etc. From the beginning, Microsoft Windows, Internet browsers and Office applications allowed almost anything do be done by scripts. Because of viruses and other types of malicious software, it is today severely restricted. In my dreams, I hope the day has now come where there is a trusted platform.

torsdag 1 oktober 2009

Google Wave and obstacles

It would be nice if all the blogs and news articles on the internet is made as Waves. Comments and responses can then be followed up in your Wave your reader without having to locate the original page. Not to mention how easy it is to add friends to the discussion.

But precisely this may also be a problem for Google Wave. A newspaper depends on their ads, and wants the users to return as much as possible. Wave reduces the need, which may mean that the newspaper chose not to use the Wave technology to publish articles.

The same problem may exist for big bloggers who earn money on their advertising.